MadSci Network: Physics |
Well, it depends. In the absence of any air resistance, the dropped and fired bullets fall at exactly the same rate, because, as you point out, the horizontal and vertical components of velocity are independent. More accurately, we would say that the horizontal and vertical components of the force on the bullet are independent. If gravity is the only force, we see that the vertical gravitational force is not affected by the bullet's horizontal motion. Let's now put in air resistance, and the situation get's more complicated. In the simplest case, we take the air resistance to be directly proportional to an object's velocity, and in the opposite direction of the velocity. The proportionality is going to depend on the amount of surface area presented in the direction of motion, e.g., a large flat board clearly experiences more air resistance than an arrow, if both are moving at the same velocity. For the bullet, what this means is that if the bullet doesn't tumble at all, remaining horizontal in both the fired and dropped cases, then in both cases the bullet falls at the same rate. The reason for this is that in the case where air resistance is directly proportional to the, the force in the vertical direction is still independent of the horizontal velocity. In physics, we call such forces "separable", because they can be separated into their various independent components which don't depend on the other components. The simple model of air resistance described above is pretty accurate in describing reality, but not perfect. Air resistance is generally more complicated. For instance, if we were to go one step better in describing air resistance, we might add a term which is still in the direction opposite to the velocity, but proportional to the *square* of the speed. In this case, the air resistance becomes a non-separable force, and the dropped and fired bullets do not fall at the same rate. However, in reality, the difference is very small. For literature, a good starting place would be a basic physics textbook like Halliday and Resnick. I wasn't able to find anything that looked relevant in our science library, however, you might check for publications from the Army or other military branches. If anyone has studied the details of bullet dynamics, it would be them.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Physics.