MadSci Network: Neuroscience |
“If a drug such as lithium carbonate alleviates symptoms of mood disorders, then it must be that mood disorders are caused ONLY by biochemical disturbances”. The answer to your question seems to be “yes” and “no”. Yes, some mood disorders do seem to be biological in nature, but environmental factors can cause mood disorders as well. Everyone experiences depression to some extent after having a bad day or after a romantic breakup. Clinical depression can also occur after a traumatic experience or after the death of a loved one. I think part of your dilemma is the mind-body “curse” that psychology and related fields have been struggling with for hundreds of years. For example, I suppose in some sense everything we do can be reduced to a biochemical process, but I don’t think this really helps us as a science. I prefer the assumption that the mind and body cannot really be divided or studied separately. Getting back to the first part of your question, it is clear that mood disorders can be brought on by biological factors. For example, we know that depression (at least clinical depression) is related to reduced levels or reduced utilization of several neurotransmitters. These include serotonin, norepinephrine and probably dopamine. For example, if you give a group of “normal” people Reserpine (which is a drug that reduces serotonin and norepinephrine in the brain) some persons (but not everyone) will become depressed. We also know that many anti-depressant drugs, such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) or the tricyclics (TCA) work by blocking reuptake of these neurotransmitters. The result is that there is an increased amount of neurotransmitter left in the synaptic cleft and more of it can reach the postsynaptic neuron (actually this is only part of the reason why antidepressants work, but the other factor is much more complicated). Monoamine oxidase inhibitors work by decreasing the enzyme monoamine oxidase, which deactivates serotonin, norepinephrine and dopamine. By decreasing monoamine oxidase, the level of these neurotransmitters also increases. You mention bipolar disorder in your question. This is an interesting disorder that is possibly caused by too much norepinephrine or perhaps an imbalance of serotonin, norepinephrine and dopamine. It is true that lithium (which is a salt) decreases symptoms in some individuals. Lithium is not really an anti-depressant. It is a mood stabilizer. However, the exact mechanism of action is not really well understood (by the way, recently lithium has been replaced as the first drug of choice for bipolar disorder by anti-seizure medications such as Valproic acid). In addition to treating mood disorders with drugs, psychological treatments have also been found to be effective. For example, some studies show that cognitive therapy is as effective as medication in treating certain types of major depression. In fact, this type of treatment may be the best over the long run because when medication is stopped, the depression often returns. This is less likely to occur with cognitive therapy. In addition, brain imaging studies done with these patients show actual brain changes after psychological treatment. So you see that even though biological factors can cause psychological disorders, psychological factors can also change biological processes. This gets back to my original idea that the mind and body should not be viewed as being separate. I hope this helps. A college level text that I recommend that you read is “Abnormal Psychology” by Gerald C. Davison and John M. Neale.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Neuroscience.