| MadSci Network: Neuroscience |
Part A: Aluminum and Alzheimer
Aluminum (Al) may be taken up from various sources such as drinking water,
aluminum containers (a minor contributor if at all), through the air we
breathe (but there is no need to worry unless you live next door to an
aluminum plant/mill or work there), through medication (antacids which give
you relief from heart burn, some forms of aspirin with a special
acid-resistant coating), antiperspirants and deoderants, (refs. 1, 5). I
have no idea though if aluminum is involved anywhere in the production of
candy or other sweets.
From all the information I gathered on the role of aluminum in Alzheimer’s
disease the picture is controversial so far (ref. 2, 5, 7). Aluminum (and
its salts) are definitely neurotoxic (i.e. they damage and kill nerve
cells) but the changes in brain structure and nerve cells this causes in
experimental animals** and man aren’t quite the same as seen in Alzheimer’s
Disease (refs. 1, 5, 7). This does not imply though that aluminum does not
cause mental impairment since it is neurotoxic after all.
Most evidence has to be studied with care. Some clinical reports show a
correlation between high concentrations of Al in drinking water and the
risk of developing AD under specified circumstances such as acid pH and low
fluoride concentration (refs. 1, 2). The chemical form in which Al is
present might play a role as well (refs. 1, 2). Keep in mind though that
it’s a mere statistical correlation which tells us nothing about causality.
Most other surveys do not confirm these findings or even refute them (refs.
1,5, 7). One should mention that risk for AD is not increased in long-term
users of antacids (which often account for a higher intake of Al than
through drinking water).
The finding that large amounts of aluminum accumulate in the brains of
AD patients is equally contended (refs. 1, 5, 7). Some critics think that
Al in the samples is a mere artifact resulting from contamination with the
metal contained in dust, fixing and staining solutions, etc. (refs. 1,7 ).
The role of aluminum in the pathogenesis, i.e. how AD is caused and what
facilitates the development of the ailment, has not conclusively been shown
since different studies report different results (reviewed in refs. 3, 5,
6). Some say Al is associated with pathological structures (senile plaques,
neurofibrillary tangles) in AD brains, others refute this or list different
explanations (refs. 5, 7).
All in all the aluminum hypothesis seems to rest on a rather shaky basis
and future research will show if there is anything to it at all.
**Historically, the whole hypothesis started out in 1965 when researchers
injected aluminum and/or its salts into the brains of rabbits and found
that this caused inflammation and damage of nerve cells in the brain (so
called encephalopathy). The pathological features weren’t the same as seen
in AD brains though.
Some reading material (more or less technical):
1. Doll R (1993). Review: Alzheimer’s Disease and Environmental Aluminium.
Age and Ageing 22: 138 - 153.
2. Forbes WF and Hill GF (1998). Is Exposure to Aluminum a Risk Factor for
the Development of Alzheimer Disease? - Yes. Archives of Neurology 55:
740 - 741.
3. Garruto RM and Brown P (1994). Tau protein, aluminium, and Alzheimer’s
Disease. [Commentary] Lancet 343: 989
4. Hachinski V (1998). Aluminum Exposure and Risk of Alzheimer Disease.
Archives of Neurology 55: 742.
5. Munoz DG (1998). Is Exposure to Aluminum a Risk Factor for the
Development of Alzheimer Disease? - No. Archives of Neurology 55: 737 -
739. [ADMIN NOTE -- THIS ARTICLE CONVINCINGLY ARGUES THAT ALUMINUM IS NOT
ASSOCIATED WITH ALZHEIMER'S.]
6. Shin R-W (1997). Interaction of Aluminum with Paired Helical Filament
Tau Is Involved in Neurofibrillary Pathology of Alzheimer’s Disease.
Gerontology 43 (suppl.): 16 - 23.
7. Storey E and Masters CL (1995). Amyloid, aluminium and the aetiology of
Alzheimer’s disease. The Medical Journal of Australia 163: 256 - 259.
Part B: How to determine the Al content in body tissue
Novel methods use an electron microscope ( transmission or scanning1, scanning2)
to analyze fixed tissue samples for its components. When you focus a high
energy electron beam onto your sample the atoms in the sample will emit
x-rays which can be analyzed in a special detector. From the data obtained
you can tell what elements and how much of them your sample contains.
By extrapolating, i.e. a kind of estimation based on the sample you
analyzed, you can calculate the approximate total Aluminum content of all
body tissues.
Alternative methods include mass spectrometry and standard quantitative
chemical analysis (e.g. by forming chemical complexes which emit light at
easily measurable wave lenghts.
Some references:
at U. of Oregon (quite easy reading)
CEA Company(technical)
at Rice U.(1) and
Rice U. (2) (technical with photos and graphics)
MicroWorld (guide to microscopy
and microanalysis)
Various Links on
Microscopy and Microanalysis (worldwide)
Any more questions or was this answer too technical? Contact me via email.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Neuroscience.