MadSci Network: Medicine
Query:

Re: Why can't doctors use a dead person's pancreas for a diabetes patients?

Date: Wed Mar 31 19:59:53 1999
Posted By: Nicole Davis, Grad student, Department of Genetics, Harvard Medical School
Area of science: Medicine
ID: 922030063.Me
Message:

Dear Alex,

Thanks for your question!  It is a very insightful one.

As you may know, diabetes mellitus is a disease characterized by abnormally 
high blood glucose levels.  Glucose is a carbohydrate, or sugar, that is 
released from ingested food and absorbed into the blood.  It is important 
for maintaining energy levels, especially during the periods between meals. 
 Under normal circumstances, insulin, a hormone produced by the pancreas, 
is released when there is a large amount of glucose in the blood.  This 
causes the tissues in the body to store the glucose so it can be used at a 
later time.  What leads to unusually high blood glucose levels in diabetic 
patients is a lack of insulin, a reduced effectiveness of this hormone, or 
a combination of these two situations.  

Diabetes essentially comes in two types.  One form is called type I 
diabetes, or insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM).  Patients with 
this form usually develop the disease when they are young, often due to the 
destruction of the cells in the pancreas which produce insulin.  These 
cells are called beta cells and are found in specialized structures in the 
pancreas called islets of Langerhans.  It is not entirely clear why these 
cells are selectively destroyed in these patients.  However, one theory is 
that the patients' immune systems recognize the beta cells as "foreign" and 
therefore, destroy these cells as they would a bacterium or other invader. 
 Therefore, without any beta cells, these patients cannot produce insulin. 
 The other form of diabetes is referred to as type II, or 
non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM).  Patients with this form 
are frequently older, and often, their beta cells are intact.  Exactly what 
causes this form is also not well understood.  It seems that many of these 
patients produce insulin, but it effectiveness is reduced.  This means 
that, although the beta cells produce insulin normally, the tissues that 
usually respond to this hormone aren't doing so.  This phenomenon is 
sometimes described as "insulin resistance".  Although I have described 
these two forms of diabetes as being very distinct, the truth is that this 
is not always the case.  Diabetes mellitus is a very complex disease and 
does not easily fit into distinct categories.

Okay, so on to your question: why don't diabetic patients get pancreas 
transplants?  Well, the truth is that they sometimes do.  However, this is 
not a routine treatment for diabetes.  As it stands now, the patients who 
normally receive pancreas transplants usually have some very serious 
complications from their disease.  High glucose levels in the blood can 
ultimately damage tissues in the body, such as the kidney, the eyes, as 
well as nerves.  Although many diabetics receive treatment to control their 
blood glucose levels, this control is not always perfect, and can still 
result in organ damage after many years of living with the disease.   For 
instance, some diabetic patients sustain serious kidney damage and need to 
undergo a kidney transplant.  Many of these patients receive a pancreas at 
the same time.  The rationale is that although medical therapy can control 
blood glucose rather well, the pancreas does it better.  However, receiving 
a new pancreas (and kidney) is not without cost--like other patients who 
receive organ transplants, these patients will have to take drugs which 
suppress their immune system for the rest of their lives.  Transplanted 
organs, even from a blood-related donor, are perceived by the recipient's 
immune system as foreign and therefore, destoyed.  Thus, unless a patient 
has an identical twin, they will need immunosuppressive drugs in order for 
the graft to survive.  This is a very serious situation--people who are on 
immunosuppressive therapy are at a much higher risk for life-threatening 
infections as well as some cancers because their defenses against these 
insults are weakened. The standard treatments for diabetes (insulin, diet 
control, etc.) are effective in controlling the disease, and they are 
getting even better.  It is true that they are not always perfect.  But, 
unless a diabetic patient must receive an organ transplant and therefore, 
will need to be on immunosuppressive drugs anyway, pancreatic transplants 
are a very risky treatment option

An emerging therapy for diabetes is islet transplantation.  Although it is 
still in an experimental stage, it may one day be an important therapeutic 
option for diabetic patients. The idea is that, rather than transplanting 
the entire pancreas, the islets themselves are transplanted.  This approach 
provides three main advantages over traditional pancreas transplants.  
First, although patients still need to take immunosuppressive drugs, they 
don't require the high doses that traditional pancreas recipients need.  
Second, these islets can be transplanted in any region of the body that has 
a rich blood supply and don't necessarily have to be put into the 
recipient's pancreas.  In fact, islets are often placed in the kidney!  
This means a less invasive surgical procedure and a speedier recovery for 
the patient.  Finally, since the islets are quite small relative to the 
entire pancreas, this means that the procedure is easier.  In addition to 
producing hormones like insulin, the pancreas is also responsible for 
making digestive enzymes and then releasing them into the intestine.  When 
the pancreas is transplanted, these intestinal connections need to be 
handled appropriately.  However, this is not necessary for islet 
transplantation.

I hope this information is helpful to you.  If you are interested, there is 
a ton of information about diabetes mellitus on the Web.  Here are a few 
sites that I think might be useful:

On-line Diabetes Resources
http://www.mendosa.com/diabetes.htm

Juvenile Diabetes Foundation 
http://www.jdfcure.org/

Joslin Diabetes Center
http://www.joslin.org/

If you have further questions, feel free to email me!

Nikki
nmdavis@fas.harvard.edu  





Current Queue | Current Queue for Medicine | Medicine archives

Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Medicine.



MadSci Home | Information | Search | Random Knowledge Generator | MadSci Archives | Mad Library | MAD Labs | MAD FAQs | Ask a ? | Join Us! | Help Support MadSci


MadSci Network, webadmin@www.madsci.org
© 1995-1999. All rights reserved.