MadSci Network: Neuroscience |
Well, I must admit I know very little about this topic. But it happens a colleague of mine is a psychiatrist and retired army colonel with a great deal of knowledge about post-traumatic stress disorder, psychiatry disorders in general, and war. So my answer comes from him (unfortunately i can't provide you with any references, though). According to my colleague, Dr. Harry Holloway, the number of psychiatric casualties was in fact not greater in Vietnam veterans than in vets of previous wars. He estimated the psychiatric casualties of Vietnam at about 9%. In World War II, there were around a million psychiatric casualties, and these casualties were in large part responsible for the growth of the VA system. The nature of the problems has indeed differed from conflict to conflict, because the types of exposures have differed (e.g., gas phobia was common after WWI because gas was commonly used in that war; numbness was a common problem in Korean vets, and hyperventilation in Vietnam vets). And media coverage was extensive after WWI - shell shock got a lot of press. However, the media may give the impression that Vietnam was worse for a number of reasons, including the one you mentioned (recency), and the fact that the war turned out badly. Dr. Holloway offered to send me some references; I will forward them to you if I receive them.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Neuroscience.