MadSci Network: Physics |
Dear Alex!
This question is posed quite often. But the `charge in free fall' paradox is only a paradox because the equivalence principle is usually not stated in its full, correct form. An accelerated reference frame is indistinguishable from a frame in a gravitational field only locally! If large extensions (like the Coulomb field of a point charge) are involved, there is no problem in detecting gravitation, because there is no such thing as a totally homogeneous graviational field. And that is why the freely falling charge will indeed radiate! (There is, of course, also the related question of why a charge at rest in a gravitational field should not radiate, and what happens if an observer accelerates and passes by a charge at rest. All theses so-called paradoxes rest on the mentioned misunderstanding.)
It is, of course, not a trivial task to establish this insight microscopically, i.e. by looking at the Poynting vector of the electromagnetic field in both reference frames. I am actually not sure whether it can be done at all - one would have to look at the Maxwell equations in gravitational fields. But that the charge will radiate is out of the question.
Hope that helps,
Georg.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Physics.