MadSci Network: Neuroscience |
There is evidence to support both sides of this question. For
example, Reed and Jensen report an equal head size for a high
IQ group and a low IQ group (Reed, T.E., & Jensen,
A.R. 1993. Cranial capacity: new Caucasian data and comments on
Rushton's claimed Mongoloid-Caucasoid brain-size
differences. Intelligence, 17, 423-431
) while Wickett
reported a relationship between head size and IQ (Wickett, J.C.,
Vernon, P.A., & Lee, D.H. 1994. In vivo brain size, head perimeter,
and intelligence in a sample of healthy adult females. Personality
and Individual Differences, 16, 831-838
). My view is that head
size is unrelated to IQ in healthy people.
The idea that head size is related to intelligence has attracted
people for years (Galton, F. 1888 Head Growth in Students at
the University of Cambridge, Nature, 38; 14-15; Pearl, R. 1906
On the Correlation between Intelligence and the Size of the
Head, Jour. Comp. Neurol. and Psychol., 16: 189-199.
) People
often draw pictures of people with larger heads than is realistic,
possibly because the human mind is what makes us ourselves
(Gellert E Children's constructions of their
self-images. Percept Mot Skills 1975 Feb;40(1):307-24
).
Another reason people might be so interested in this is that we might
like to be able to 'judge a book by its cover', and tell if someone
was smart just by looking at them.
There are two real questions at the center of the question of whether
head size is related to IQ. One is whether the authors are trying to
prove that a certain 'type' of person is smarter than another.
J. P. Rushton is an example of this. Rushton straightforwardly states
his belief that "evolution is progressive and that some populations
are more 'advanced' than others" (Rushton JP Contributions to
the history of psychology: XC. Evolutionary biology and heritable
traits (with reference to oriental-white-black differences): the 1989
AAAS paper. Psychol Rep 1992 Dec;71(3 Pt 1):811-21
). What
he does not state is that these beliefs may be influencing the way he
does his research, and therefore he may be finding evidence for what
he wants to find. This introduction of bias into research is an
important problem, and of great ethical importance in research that
addresses differences supposedly due to race or sex (Kaufman JS;
Cooper RS; McGee DL Socioeconomic status and health in blacks and
whites: the problem of residual confounding and the resiliency of race
Epidemiology 1997 Nov;8(6):621-8
). Rushton says that brain
size is related to IQ in normal adults (Rushton, J.P. 1992
Cranial capacity related to sex, rank and race in a stratified
random sample of 6325 U.S. military personnel. Intelligence, 16,
401-413; Rushton JP, Ankney CD Brain size matters: a reply to
Peters. Can J Exp Psychol. 1995 Dec;49(4):562-9; discussion
570-6
). It is my opinion that Rushton uses bad science (http://goinside.com/98/3/postmod.ht
ml;
http://www.sciam.com/1197issue/1197review1.html) to support
racist views.
The second question at the center of the relationship of head size to
IQ is whether other factors are affecting the results. Other factors
such as nutrition may be involved, and correcting for these factors
may eliminate the relationship between head size and IQ
(Passingham RE Brain size and intelligence in man. Brain
Behav Evol 1979;16(4):253-70
). Michael Peter says that
(Canadian Journal
of Experimental Psychology (Vol. 49, No. 4))
which you can find
at
http://www.coe.ilstu.edu/portfolios/students/actaylo/rushton-.htm
and "Unsolved Problems in Comparing Brain Sizes in Homo Sapiens
" by M. Peters, L. Jäncke, J. F. Staiger, G. Schlaug, Y. Huang,
H. Steinmetz, published in Brain and Cognition, Vol. 37, No. 2, July
1998 pp. 254-285
. Dr. Peter's web page is accessible through
http://www.psych
ology.uoguelph.ca/newhome/psy.html.
In people who are not able to grow healthily either before or after
birth, head size may be related to mental function (Hack M;
Breslau N; Weissman B; Aram D; Klein N; Borawski E. Effect of very
low birth weight and subnormal head size on cognitive abilities at
school age N Engl J Med 1991 Jul 25;325(4):231-7
) These
researchers found that babies who weighed less than 1.5 kg (about 3
and a half pounds) at birth, and who did not grow as large as most
babies at eight months, also had lower IQ scores. This research
suggests that brain development, and therefore IQ, was affected by the
same factors that affected overall growth and head size in these
children. When pregnant women were exposed to radiation during the
tragic bombing of Hiroshima, their babies had both small head size and
mental retardation. (Miller RW Effects of prenatal exposure
to ionizing radiation. Health Phys 1990 Jul;59(1):57-61
)
Children who were exposed to rubella before they were born, who were
smaller than average and had smaller than average head size, had
normal IQs (Macfarlane DW; Boyd RD; Dodrill CB; Tufts E
Intrauterine rubella, head size, and intellect. Pediatrics 1975
Jun;55(6):797-801
). Even in children with a medical problem in
which the pressure of the fluid in their brains is very high, the IQ
score is not a good measure of intellectual ability because some of
their mental abilities are affected (mostly motor skills) and some are
not (Hammock MK; Milhorat TH; Baron IS Normal pressure
hydrocephalus in patients with myelomeningocele. Dev Med Child
Neurol Suppl 1976;(37):55-68
). So even in people with abnormal
growth and brain development, IQ and head size may not be related.
Finally, Mark Tramo has the last word in his article "Brain
size, head size, and intelligence quotient in monozygotic twins."
By MJ Tramo; WC Loftus; TA Stukel; RL Green; JB Weaver; & MS
Gazzaniga, published in Neurology, Vol 50, No 5, May 1998,
pp. 1246-52
. Dr. Tramo uses magnetic resonance imaging (http://128.227.164.224/mrituto
r/index.html)
to look at the relationship of head size and Intelligence Quotient
(IQ) in twins. They found that twins had similar brain size, body
weight, head size, and IQ. Brain size and head size were related.
But IQ was not related to brain size or head size. These scientists
decided that brain size was related to head size, but not to IQ in
young, healthy adults.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Neuroscience.