|MadSci Network: Physics|
Hello Duke, An interesting question, and one that has a couple of answers; depending on certain assumptions. Designing an antenna is a very complex science in itself, but I will try to keep it simple. The purpose of an antenna is to gather radio frequency signals from the air and connect them to the input stages of the receiver. The input stages are compromised of an oscillator (usually user- tuneable, as in a transistor radio) which allows you to tune to a selected station, and one or more I.F. (intermediate frequency) amplifier stages which take the weak signal and amplify it to a usable level. In a cellular telephone, it is not necessary to be able to tune the oscillator because the frequency range is preset by your service provider, and one of the many individual frequencies, or channels, available are automatically selected, and allows the transmitting cell to select a currently unused channel for a call to you. Your 'phone is able to accept signals on any of the available channels. While it is theoretically possible to add many I.F. amplifiers to gain the necessary signal strength, the problem with that approach is that they not only amplify the desired signal, but all the other frequencies (noise) as well. Seperating the noise from the signal is no easy task, so it is far better to use an antenna which provides gain at the correct frequency, and tends to eliminate the other frequencies. To illustrate antenna gain, think of it as a length of clothesline, stretched between a fixed point at one end and your hand at the other. As you move your hand up and down, you will create a wave in the line, which will travel from your hand to the other end and return to your hand. This represents the radio signal. If you move your hand up and down at just the right speed, the returning wave will reach your hand in exactly the same relationship as your hand movement, causing the resulting wave to be the sum of the two waves. In other words, you have just amplified the original signal by 2, discounting any losses that may be incurred, and the receiving (fixed) end will see a signal that is approx. twice the original signal strength. This amplification is dependent on the length of the antenna (clothesline), and the frequency of the applied signal. If the antenna is the wrong length, the returning waves may partially or even completely cancel out the desired signal. That's why "rabbit ear" antennas for tv's were adjustable in length; so you could tune it for the channel you were watching. Getting more specific, radio waves travel at the speed of light, or 186,000 miles per second. If you convert this to inches/sec, you get 11,784,960,000 which, when divided by the frequency used by a normal cell phone of 900MHz, you get a wavelength of 13.0944 inches. This is the distance between upper-most and lower-most points of ONE cycle. Therefore, the ideal length for a 900MHz cell phone antenna would be 13.0944 inches. Because this is not practicle, a sub-multiple of the ideal length is used - such as 1/2, 1/4, 1/8, etc. Any such fraction (within limits) is o.k. as long as it is divisible by two. If you use a factor such as 1/3rd, it will cause the incoming waves to collide with returning waves, creating what are called "standing waves", and the efficiency of the antenna will be significantly impaired. Now, as to using metal strips: If the strips are the correct length, it is POSSIBLE that they can improve reception given that one of two facts are true. 1. The strip is electrically connected to the built-in antenna at the antennas attachment point (the length of the connecting wire becomes part of the equation) or 2. The strip is inductively coupled to the antenna or I.F. circuit. This inductive coupling is based on the fact that when an electric current is passed thru a wire (the "strip antenna" in this case), it will induce a current in another wire running more-or-less parallel to it. If the two "wires" are perpendicular to each other, no inductive current is realized. To summarize: As the inductive current flow is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the wires, you can see that the placement and positioning of the strip is critical, and not knowing where the proper wire is located in your phone and its' direction of run, any advantage you would see would be purely coincidental. Also, since high frequency radio signals travel in a line-of-sight manner only, you would gain no advantage in those areas commonly known as "Black Holes". I hope this helps you understand this antenna "snake oil". Your not-so-mad scientist, Karl KarlKolbus@ameritech.net
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Physics.