MadSci Network: Physics |
It's hard to answer a question like that in general, because "dangerous" depends on the context. There are specific situations where one or the other would be more "dangerous." But the most common danger would be that of being burned when it comes into contact with your skin. And there, steam is generally more dangerous. To understand why, you need to think about what happens when you get burned. The steam or water gives up energy to your skin (until it has given up enough to be cooled down to skin temperature), and if it is too much energy it causes damage. Now think about boiling a pan of water on a stove. You have to put in some energy to get it up to the boiling temperature. Then you have to put in a bunch more energy to get it to boil. So steam has a much higher energy content per gram than liquid water at the same temperature. All this energy is available to burn you above and beyond what the hot water would burn you, making steam more dangerous. Now a little bit of a curve ball. The answer I just gave is based on dangers of steam in industry, where it is often used at fairly high pressures. So it would apply, for example, to the difference between pressurized steam and water both at 200 degrees C. You specifically asked about 100 degrees C. Boiling there is at atmospheric pressure, so the steam is pretty dilute. So even though each gram of steam would have much more burning potential than a gram of hot water, low-pressure steam is spread out enough that the amount of H2O that contacts you is relatively small. That's why you can hold your hand (at least briefly!) in the steam above a boiling pan of water when water from the pan splashing onto your hand would scald you. But if you're in a situation where the steam is fairly concentrated, like if it is high-pressure or if it is directed out a nozzle (such as when your teakettle whistles), then steam is quite dangerous.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Physics.