MadSci Network: Physics
Query:

Re: Can we not divert a thunderbolt using some +ve or -ve charge?

Date: Tue Mar 25 21:31:18 2003
Posted By: William Payne, , Electromagnetics, Altair
Area of science: Physics
ID: 1048239475.Ph
Message:

In principle what you suggest is possible.  An artificial arc was
experimentally produced over 30m long.  Since it was impractical to create 
high enough voltage or strong enough insulation to produce it directly, 
the arc was launched into the air by ionization, and steered by external 
electrodes, much as you suggest.

In practice, the difficult part of taming the natural thunderbolt is you 
have little control or knowledge on the upper part of the circuit, the 
cloud.  Large electrical charges are displaced through the earth mirroring 
the charges above, until the thunderbolt discharges them.

At the ground, you can control thunderbolts more easily by simply 
controlling the height of the grounded objects.  This is the "lightning-
rod" developed by Dr Benjamin Franklin.  It naturally takes advantage of 
the factor "inversely with the square of the distance", by increasing the 
height of the rod we reduce the distance to the cloud and increase the 
attraction.

The field gradient is how steeply the voltage changes.  At low gradients 
we can apply electrical charges to change the shape and gradient of the 
field near the rod.  However, the natural voltage will reach many 
thousands of volts per cm before a thunderbolt strikes, so at a distance 
away from the rod any artificial voltage that we could achieve has very 
small effect on the total field.

If we could watch lightning form in slow motion, we would normally see a 
dim "stepped leader" about 1m diameter descending in steps of about 50m, 
with a short pause between each step.  This establishes a channel that 
would be followed by several "return strokes" that follow the channel 
upward, delivering the electrical energy that produces the bright flashes 
we see.  To control the path of the return stroke, one must control the 
evolution of the stepped leader.


NASA Primer on 
Lightning: 

My web page has some electrical data on 
lightning

The "Earth Circuit" has a voltage of 500,000 volts + upwards, at a height 
of about 80 km all over the earth.  The total capacitance is about 0.25 
Farads with a leakage resistance of 200 ohms, and leakage current of 2500 
amperes, that would deplete the charge in less than one minute.  The 
combined atmospheric electrical activity over the earth constantly 
replaces this charge, delivering about 1250 megawatts of power.  The 
entire "Earth Circuit" is equal to almost 2% of the electrical power needs 
of India.

Best Regards,
Altair
www.altair.org


Current Queue | Current Queue for Physics | Physics archives

Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Physics.



MadSci Home | Information | Search | Random Knowledge Generator | MadSci Archives | Mad Library | MAD Labs | MAD FAQs | Ask a ? | Join Us! | Help Support MadSci


MadSci Network, webadmin@www.madsci.org
© 1995-2003. All rights reserved.