MadSci Network: General Biology |
Your question brings up a common misconception in the field of genetics: that dominant traits are the most common ones. That is not necessarily true. The gene for Huntington's disease is dominant, yet most people do not have it. The gene for 6-fingered dwarfism is dominant, yet most people are clearly not 6-fingered dwarfs. How common a particular trait is within the population depends not only on whether it's dominant or recessive, but what the frequency of the gene is within the gene pool. As your students probably know, ABO blood type is determined by a single gene. Each person has 2 copies, and there are three different alleles: A, B and O (usually represented by i) A and B are codominant to each other, and both are dominant to i. So: Type A can be AA or Ai Type B can be BB or Bi Type AB is AB and type O is ii. However, these alleles do not appear with equal frequency in the gene pool. i is much more common than A, which is more common than B. It should be easy to see then, why more people have type A blood than type B. However, there are so many more i's out there in the gene pool that the chances of getting ii are higher than Ai. So O is the most common blood type. To illustrate this, imagine a bag of marbles. Let black marbles be the most common allele. In the example of 6-fingered dwarfism, black would be the gene for 5 fingers and normal height. 6-fingered dwarfism is a very rare allele to find, so throw in a couple of red marbles to represent it. Then draw marbles out, two by two, replacing them in the bag each time. If you have only a few red and hundreds of black, most of the time you will wind up with 2 black, which is a normal phenotype. It only takes 1 red one to give a 6-fingered dwarf, but that is going to happen only rarely, because the reds are overwhelmingly outnumbered by blacks. The illustration could be expanded to include blood type by making the black marbles i, red marbles A and green marbles B. Your bag will have mostly blacks, some reds, and even fewer greens. Reds and greens are not as rare here as they were in the previous example, but they are still less common than blacks, so that the odds of pulling out 2 blacks will be higher than pulling out a black and a red, or a black and a green, or two reds, or two greens, or a red and a green. So Type O > Type A (AA + Ai) > Type B (BB + Bi) > AB. (Note that, in this case, BB (2 greens) would actually be the rarest thing to get. Being homozygous for B is actually rarer than type AB blood, but since type B blood includes all Bi's and BB's, type B blood is more common than AB.) If you know the frequencies of alleles in the population, you can calculate the frequency of the various geneotypes and phenotypes. Perhaps an interesting problem for your students would be: What does the frequency of a recessive allele have to be for the recessive phenotype to be more common than the dominant one? Thank you for your question. Louise Freeman
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on General Biology.