MadSci Network: Botany
Query:

Re: Why did Goerge Washington Carver Jr. come up with the things he invented?

Date: Thu Nov 29 20:13:58 2001
Posted By: David Hershey, Faculty, Botany, NA
Area of science: Botany
ID: 1006212044.Bt
Message:

Carver worked at the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama and for the U.S. 
Agricultural Experiment Station. He wanted to help farmers in the South live 
better and be more profitable. In the early 1900s, cotton was devastated by the 
boll weevil so Southern farmers needed other crops. Compared to cotton, the 
peanut was a much better crop to improve the soil because it fixed nitrogen 
plus it was a nutritious food that poor farmers could use to improve their 
diet. Carver wanted to create a greater demand for peanuts as a cash crop by 
using them in more products. Carver got a lot of publicity for the 325 products 
he made from peanuts but none of them was a commercial success. Carver also 
made 75 products from pecans and 108 from sweet potatoes but none of those 
products was a commercial success either. 

Carver's accomplishments were greatly exagerated even during his lifetime and 
still are. Many textbooks say that Carver singlehandedly diversified Southern 
agriculture but given that his products were not commercially successful, his 
inventions had virtually no impact on Southern agriculture. They did bring him 
great fame. One of Carver's real innovations was his school-on-wheels where he 
visited farmers and informed them of the latest farming practices. Carver won 
many awards during his lifetime and is probably still the best known African-
American scientist. Carver lived frugally and saved most of his $1,000 annual 
salary. He used his substantial life savings to set up a foundation to continue 
his work.

Carver's fame got a huge boost in 1921 when the peanut growers asked Carver to 
appear before the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Ways and Means 
regarding a tariff on peanuts. The tariff was to protect domestic peanut 
farmers from cheap imports. Carver so impressed the committee with his peanut 
products that he spoke longer than normal. Carver got a lot of the credit when 
the tariff passed and a great deal of publicity. However, the big peanut 
growers reaped the financial rewards.

Probably the best biography of Carver is the one by Linda McMurray quoted in 
the first webpage. She explains how it is difficult to separate Carver's actual 
accomplishments from the many Carver myths. If you really want to learn about 
Carver's work, you would need to read his papers, which are available on 
microfilm.

Some other frequent Carver myths:

1. Carver invented peanut butter. Actually, peanut butter was first sold in the 
1890s before Carver even started working on peanuts. 

2. Carver generously gave all his inventions to the public and his explanation 
was often quoted "God gave them to me. How can I sell them to someone else?" 
Actually, Carver set up the Carver Products Company to try to make money on his 
products but none were ever commercially successful.

3. Thomas Edison offered Carver $100,000 per year to work for him. Although 
Carver mentioned this in his speeches, he would not explain further when 
reporters questioned him about it, and Edison's company had no records to 
confirm such as offer was ever made. Edison died in 1931, well before Carver, 
so Edison could not confirm or deny Carver's story.


References


George Washington Carver, Jr.: Chemurgist


George Washington Carver


George Washington Carver websites


George Washington Carver annotated bibliography


The Papers of George Washington Carver


History of Peanut Butter


Boll Weevil and Southern Agriculture



Current Queue | Current Queue for Botany | Botany archives

Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Botany.



MadSci Home | Information | Search | Random Knowledge Generator | MadSci Archives | Mad Library | MAD Labs | MAD FAQs | Ask a ? | Join Us! | Help Support MadSci


MadSci Network, webadmin@www.madsci.org
© 1995-2001. All rights reserved.