MadSci Network: Engineering
Query:

Re: Which type of thermometer indicate a small rise in temperature faster?

Date: Fri Jul 21 13:18:41 2006
Posted By: Jay Shapiro, Staff, Engineering, TA Aerospace
Area of science: Engineering
ID: 1149298879.Eg
Message:

Hello Lim,
You have some interesting questions!

First, I would like to give a little background on how a thermometer 
works:  The principle behind a mercury (or alcohol) thermometer is that 
the liquid expands at a precise rate with increases in temperature(and 
shrinks with decreasing temperature).  In theory, you could take a 
kitchen measuring cup, fill it to the one-cup level with mercury,and 
measure temperature changes by looking at how the liquid level changes.  
The problem is that the volume change with moderate temperature changes 
is very small-

Mercury has a 'volumetric thermal expansion rate' of only .000018 per 
degree C.  This means, that for a 10 degree C rise, the volume will 
increase by only 10 x .000018 = .00018 times the original volume.  Our 
measuring cup volume will increase to only 1.00018 cups! This would be 
impossible to measure. (Also, mercury is very hazardous to handle).

So how does a thermometer solve this problem?  A thermometer is simply a 
device that allows us to accurately measure very small changes in 
volume.  The 'bulb' of the thermometer contains a volume of mercury.  It 
is connected to a VERY small diameter 'capillary tube'.  

Because of the connection, when the temperature changes and the mercury 
expands, virtually ALL of the additional volume is forced into the 
capillary tube.  This has the effect of greatly magnifying the ability to 
see the volume change.

With this information, we can address your questions:

a)If you have 2 thermometers, identical except for bulb size, what will 
happen to each with an equal temperature rise?:  The mercury in the small 
bulb will expand a small percent of its original volume.  The added 
volume will flow up into the capillary tube, some distance.  

The mercury in the large bulb unit would expand the same 'percentage', 
but will have a proportionately larger volume that will flow into the 
tube.  This volume will fill a greater length of the tube, and will hit 
the end stop at the top of the thermometer sooner than the small bulb 
unit.  THEREFORE, the small bulb unit will have a larger temperature 
range of measurement. 

b) Because the larger unit would move more fluid into the tube, it will 
give a faster, more precise (magnified) reading of a temperature change 
compared to the small unit. 

c)Because alcohol has a smaller volume expansion rate than mercury 
(.000011 vs. .000018)**, both our small and large bulb thermometers would 
have a smaller movement of the fluid in the tube for a given temperature 
change. The ratios would still be the same though, and the small bulb 
unit would still allow for a larger temperature range of measurement.

The references below will give you more information.

I hope that this helps!

Regards,

Jay Shapiro
 http://www.answers.com/topic/coefficient-of-thermal-
expansion
 http://www.answers.com/topic/mercury-in-glass-thermometer-1

** http://www.
cord.edu/dept/physics/p128/lecture98_36.html


Current Queue | Current Queue for Engineering | Engineering archives

Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Engineering.



MadSci Home | Information | Search | Random Knowledge Generator | MadSci Archives | Mad Library | MAD Labs | MAD FAQs | Ask a ? | Join Us! | Help Support MadSci


MadSci Network, webadmin@madsci.org
© 1995-2006. All rights reserved.