MadSci Network: Physics
Query:

Re: Do gravitons carry gravitational force or cause it?

Date: Wed Nov 10 19:12:56 1999
Posted By: Layne Johnson, Undergraduate
Area of science: Physics
ID: 942240231.Ph
Message:

Hello, Kirk.

Gravitons supposedly carry gravitational attraction.  They do not cause it. 
I say "supposedly" because gravitons might not exist.

In the universe we know of four fundamental forces; electro-magnetism 
(electricity and magnetism), the strong nuclear force (which holds atoms 
together), the weak nuclear force (which causes radioactive decay), and 
gravity (which keeps me from slam dunking a basketball, no matter how hard 
I try).  Each of these forces is carried accross distances by sub-atomic 
particles called bosons.  It's a little misleading to call bosons 
"particles" because they have no mass and behave somewhat like waves.  The 
electro-magnetic force is carried by photons.  The strong nuclear force is 
carried by gluons.  The weak force is carried by weak bosons, and gravity 
is carried by gravitons.

Or so we thought.  Earlier in this decade, it was shown in a brilliant 
piece of detective work by Sheldon Glashow, Abdus Salam, and Steven 
Weinberg that the electro-magnetic force and the weak nuclear force are 
actually one and the same.  Radio-active decay is carried by photons after 
all, and weak bosons don't exist.

It's very possible that the graviton doesn't exist, either.  It's predicted 
mathematically, but so were weak bosons.  Once it was found that the weak 
nuclear force was just a manifestation of electro-magnetism, it was 
realized that the basis for predicting weak bosons was faulty.

If gravity is ever unified with the other forces, then gravitons won't be 
needed anymore, and the theory will be discarded.

It's interesting to note that of the sub-atomic particles we've observed so 
far (over 400!), we've yet to see the graviton.

But let's assume that gravitons do exist, and are just what the standard 
model predicts they are - massless bosons with two units of spin 
charge.

Gravitons carry gravitational attraction between two massive bodies, in the 
same way that photons carry magnetism, or gluons hold electrons in orbit 
around nuclei.  How exactly that's done hasn't been explained.  But I'll 
give you my opinion about it.

Everywhere, even in a complete vacuum, there exists a sub-atomic network of 
lines.  They connect everything to everything else.  Every particle is 
linked to every other particle in the universe by these lines.  They can't 
be seen or detected, because they're not comprised of matter.  But to help 
us visualize this, we will imagine that these lines are actually ropes, 
tying everything together.  The difference between our imaginary ropes and 
real ropes cowboys use is that our ropes can pass through other ropes, and 
no damage is done.  

The gravitational attraction between two bodies can be explained by waves 
in the rope.  Remember, the graviton exhibits wave-like behavior as well as 
particle-like behavior.  Since our rope can't stretch or break, waves 
shrink the distance between the two bodies, like this -

  0------------------------0
           _   _   _
       0\_/ \_/ \_/ \0

If this is the behavior of gravitons, we never can find them in particle 
accelerators.  They're not particles being emmitted from massive bodies, 
they're waves traveling along the network of lines that connects massive 
bodies.  Their ability to carry the force of gravity is due to their 
wave-like behavior, not their particle-like behavior.

It makes more sense that way.

Unfortunately, quantum happenings don't have to make sense.  I may have it 
all wrong.  I'll leave you with two quotes from two of the fathers of 
quantum physics.

"I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics" - 
Richard Feynman

"If you're not confused by quantum mechanics, you really don't understand 
it" - Niels Bohr

I hope I was of some help,

Layne Johnson


Current Queue | Current Queue for Physics | Physics archives

Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Physics.



MadSci Home | Information | Search | Random Knowledge Generator | MadSci Archives | Mad Library | MAD Labs | MAD FAQs | Ask a ? | Join Us! | Help Support MadSci


MadSci Network, webadmin@www.madsci.org
© 1995-1999. All rights reserved.