MadSci Network: Astronomy |
Thanks for your question! Honestly, I had never heard of a supposed alignment between the pyramids in Egypt and the stars in the belt of Orion. I therefore spent some of my lunch hour surfing on the Web and read many interesting pages on the subject. I must say that I am very skeptical. Humans are extremely good at recognizing patterns and similarities, so even if the pyramids did line up with the arrangements of Orion it may not matter much. Besides, there are many other places in the sky with a number of bright stars in a row, so a clever person could find other alignments. Look at all the geographical features on the Earth that are named after animals (Beaver Mountain, etc.), which have nothing to do with real animals. I also am skeptical because most of the time these things turn out not to mean much (for example, the "face" on Mars or the "canals" on Mars, which are not real). There is, however, an important issue about the way science works that is raised by this suggestion about an astronomical connection to ancient construction. Bauval's suggestion of an alignment counts as a hypothesis, a provisional idea which leads to further investigation. No matter how precise the alignment is, we would need OTHER supporting evidence that this is real and not a coincidence. If we found, for example, historical records about the actual motivations of the pyramid builders, we would know what they really intended. The biggest problem is knowing how to verify such supposed alignments. Where will supporting evidence come from? If we don't have any supporting evidence, this remains just an interesting idea.
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Astronomy.