| MadSci Network: Chemistry |
Aloha, Melissa,
You have asked a very interesting question about milk and water.
Instead of answering it directly for you, how about I lead you through a
series of experiments that should give you the answers?
First, to test the boiling point of water and milk, you need to have a
scientific-quality thermometer. Check with your science teacher to see if
you can borrow one. You can actually do these experiments at home.
Regarding the boiling point of milk compared to water: Decide on a
reasonable amount of fluid to work with; I'd suggest a cup of fluid in a
small pan. Put the fluid on a stove burner (or alternately in the
microwave oven in a microwave-proof container). Bring it carefully to a
rolling boil and measure the temperature at full boil, being careful NOT to
let the thermometer bulb touch the bottom of the container (you'll get an
incorrect reading that way).
I'd suggest that you do water and several varieties of milk (non-fat,
1 or 2%, and whole milk..and maybe even cream or regular evaporated milk).
What will you predict? Will milk be boiling at a higher temperature than
water? Any idea why? You may need some help from a foods teacher
regarding the nutrient composition of milk.
For the second part of your question, related to the fat content: You
may already have some idea of the answer, once you try several kinds of
milk. To check it out further, in a scientific manner, start with non-fat
milk and add equal measures of vegetable oil, such as 1 Tbsp, 2 Tbsp, 3
Tbsp, etc...and try the boiling experiment again. If you don't see any
change with these, try adding 5 Tbsp of oil. This experiment isn't exactly
like milk, since the fat in milk (when there is some) is actually in
suspension (homogenized), but I think it will be a pretty good first
approximation.
Just as a warning, be very careful, especially if you choose to
microwave the fluids, rather than boiling them on a stove burner. Best to
have another person, preferrably an adult, around while you do this. The
liquids can spatter and burn easily, particularly the milk and the milk
with oil added.
Good luck with the experiments.
Dian Dooley
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Chemistry.