MadSci Network: Evolution |
You've asked an interesting question, actually two questions, one about the origin of multicellularity and another about differentiation during development. Your basic information is correct. Prior to cell division, genetic material is copied. As you probably know, the DNA molecule has two complementary halves; each half acts as a template to form a new complementary half. Mitosis is a process that separates the two identical sets of chromosomes. Usually mitosis is coupled with cytokinesis, a process that divides the cytoplasm producing two separate cells. Since multicellular organisms arise from a single cell, every cell has exactly the same genetic information. It seems most logical to answer the last question first. First multicellularity exists in a range of different forms. In some multicellular organisms all cells are identical and therefore perform similar functions. In other multicellular organisms cells may differentiate into specialized forms for specialized functions. In simple organisms, only occasional cells may have specialized functions. In others virtually all cells may become specialized to form familiar tissues and organs. But while all these specialized cells are genetically identical, different sets of genes, different portions of these genetic instructions, are being followed. The developmental process is how cells obtain information about their "location" and what set of instructions to follow. Developmental biology studies how genes are regulated, turned on and turned off, as an organism develops from a single cell. It's sort of like a map to a city. All maps are identical, but different people follow different routes to arrive at different destinations. Very simple organisms have much simpler genetic programs. Consider a very simple organism, a filamentous algae. A filament is a chain of identical cells, although some filamentous algae do produce specialized cells. The developmental program, in descriptive language, says to a cell, divide at right angles to your long axis. This set of instructions is simply repeated to produce a filament. If a second set of instructions was added, a more complex form could be produced. For example, every 10th time, divide parallel to your long axis then return to dividing at right angles. This will produce a branching filament. Obviously more complex forms develop from the addition of new sets of instructions, which must be derived from the instructions that already exist. In other words, you wouldn't expect a whole new set of instructions to just magically appear; you might however expect a new set of instructions that are just a little different from some set of instructions the cell already has. And we know how such differences happen, mutations during DNA duplication. Now let's address your first question. How did multicellularity arise? Obviously from a small change in the instructions on how to divide into two separate cells, the most common form of asexual reproduction. If for example you were to watch a large number of Chlamydomonas cell divide, you will occasionally see a double cell resulting from a failure of cytokinesis. Perhaps this happens because of some mutation that causes a failure to separate. Most likely the failure will result in the early death of the double cell. This is a form of natural selection and an example of how it works, in this case by weeding out mutations. But suppose the mutation only causes separation failure, say once every 20 divisions or so. Since it works OK 19 out of 20 times, the mutated instructions survive in the population even if the one of 20 dies. But how could this become the regular case? If for some reason the double cell found itself at an advantage, where it thrived instead of died, then natural selection would be reversed to favor the mutation. Now I have no idea about what might cause selection for a double cell that could lead to multiple celled colonies and finally a magnificent organism like Volvox. However, let's consider another example, a very simple seaweed, a single celled algae anchored to a rock. Space is very limited on something like a rock, so a larger size would allow this simple seaweed to compete better for space and therefore light. So maybe it spreads out broadly, and this works fine, until a different simple seaweed moves into the adjacent space. Rather than have a short, broad cell, the new seaweed produces a tall, slender cell that shades the short, broad cell, so the tall slender cell is a better competitor for light under these conditions. Maybe a third even taller seaweed arrives, but this competitive race will end because there is a size limitation on single cells for both functional reasons (cells must maintain a functional volume to surface area) and structural reasons (big water balloons break easier than small water balloons). If one of these single celled seaweeds had a mutation to its genetic program for dividing and failing separate every 20th time, similar to the one described above, then the production of a filament would be of real competive advantage allowing an even bigger size via multicellularity. So that's the basic answer. What was originally a mistake in the genetic instructions to divide and separate became instructions for making a simple multicellular organism (divide the cell, but don't separate), and for some reason, in this case compeition for light, the multicellular condition was an advantage. This is how evolution works. A random process, mutation, causes variants, many of which aren't functional at all. But some variants exist. Changing environmental conditions select among variants, favoring some and not others. Favored sets of instructions, even altered ones, become a part of the organism's genetic instructions. Complex sets of developmental instructions represent an accumulation of successful mistakes. Again think of the map analogy. You learn a new route to a new location by retracing part of an old route and adding some new instructions to it. Where's the new Thai restaurant (I'm always hoping)? Well, you know how to get to the grease-burger palace? Well, rather than turning right by the school, just go one block further and turn right. I found it by accidentally missing the turn. And then you discover you like Thai food so much, you never return to the burger palace. So now the instructions have become the route to phad thai not to fries. Where's the bicycle shop where you got the cool recumbent bike that replaced your gas guzzler (still always hoping)? Well, you know how to get to Bangkok Palace? See how things develop?
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Evolution.