MadSci Network: Botany |
According to the USDA food database (first reference), bottled or canned lemon juice contains 2.4% sugar by weight (24 grams per liter). A high concentration of sugar reduces the availability of water to the seed. If the seed cannot absorb water, it cannot germinate. As you saw, sugars can also promote microbe growth. Microbes produce waste products that can be toxic to plants. Plant cells absorb water because they contain a higher concentration of dissolved substances than the soil solution. If the soil solution contains high concentrations of dissolved substances, such as sugars or salts, the seed or root cannot absorb water. Irrigating plants with sugar or human beverages that contain sugar, such as sodas or fruit juices, seems to be a very popular project judging from the large number of questions submitted to MadSci. I don't recommend projects that involve irrigating plants with human beverages for the following reasons: 1. Human beverages are too expensive to be practical alternatives to tap water or fertilizer solutions for plant irrigation. 2. Photosynthetic plants are autotrophic so beverages designed for heterotrophic humans do not make sense biologically for use on plants. Autotrophic organisms make all the sugars and other organic compounds they require. 3. Students are often unable to explain results of such projects. 4. There are many, many better plant projects relating to plant nutrition and plant water relations such as the following: a. Plant growth with different types or amounts of fertilizers. b. Plant growth in soil and without soil (hydroponics). c. Plant growth with and without carbon dioxide. d. Plant nutrient deficiency symptoms. e. Effects of soil salinity on plant growth. f. Plant growth with different amounts of water. A long list of potential plant projects is found in the following answer: Re: could u give me some ideas about a science project with beans? The second reference suggests some good experiments involving sugar and plants. Sugar can be used to extend the vase life of cut flowers or to keep albino corn seedlings alive. References USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference Re: What is a good plant to test the effects of sugar or sweetener? Re: Why did the liquids kill the plants? Why did the tea do well? Re: Why will plants grow in Diet Coke and water and not other sodas? Re: Can bean seeds grow with milk? Re: will plants consume milk and orange juice?
Try the links in the MadSci Library for more information on Botany.